IRA to IRA Transfers and Rollovers can seem similar in nature, but contain unique characteristics. Below, we've outlined some specifics to help you distinguish between the two and help you determine which is right for you.
Select to Open Now
An IRA-to-IRA transfer generally is the easiest way to move assets between IRAs. A transfer usually occurs between two separate financial organizations, but a transfer also may occur between IRAs held at the same organization.
The IRA owner directs the transfer, but doesn't receive the assets directly. Instead, the distributing and receiving organizations handle the transaction.
This process is non-taxable, non-reportable, and can be done as often as needed.
Between like IRAs
Transfers can occur between similar types of IRAs. This includes:
No constructive receipt of assets
The IRA owner must not receive the assets directly. Instead, the check must be made payable to the receiving financial organization. If transferring stock or property "in-kind," it must be re-registered in the name of the new financial organization. The IRA owner can hand deliver the check to the receiving organization as long as it is properly issued.
No reporting
These transfers are not reported to the federal government or the IRA owner. The distributing organization does not generate Form 1099-R to report a distribution, and the receiving organization does not report the transfer deposit as a contribution on Form 5498.
No withholding
Federal income tax withholding requirements do not apply to IRA-to-IRA transfers because these transactions are not considered IRA distributions.
Unlimited number of transfers
An IRA owner may make an unlimited number of transfers in a year. The transfers may be for all or any part of an IRA.
Select to Open Now
An IRA Rollover is a tax-free way to move assets from one IRA to another. Unlike transfers, where the assets move directly between IRAs, rollovers involve the individual receiving the money or property first before depositing it into another IRA. Because of this, financial organizations must report rollover transactions to the IRS.
IRS limits IRA rollovers to one (1) per 12 month period. Some funds may not be eligible for rollover. Please consult a tax advisor.
Constructive receipt of assets
Before the rollover, the IRA owner receives a distribution of the assets, meaning the check is made payable to the IRA owner. The owner can either keep the assets and claim the assets as income, or roll them over into an IRA.
Reporting requirements
Like any other IRA distribution, a distribution intended for rollover must be reported on Form 1099-R. For Traditional IRA distributions, financial organizations use code 1 (Early distribution, no known exception), or code 7 (Normal distribution), depending on whether the distribution recipient is under or over 59 1/2 years of age. If a spouse beneficiary rolls over assets from a deceased spouse's Traditional IRA, code 4 (Death) is used. For Roth IRA distributions, financial organizations use:
Upon completion of the rollover, the receiving financial organization reports the rollover contribution on Form 5498 in Box 2.
Recipients of eligible distributions generally have 60 days from the day they physically receive the assets to deposit them into an IRA. An IRA rollover contribution made by mail is considered timely if the envelope is postmarked by the 60th day.
IRA owner applied for waiver
IRA owners may apply to the IRS for a waiver of the 60-day rollover restriction under the private letter ruling (PLR) rules outlined in Rev. Proc. 2016-8. The PLR request fee for the wavier is $10,000. If approved, only the distribution amount (excluding earned interest) is eligible for rollover.
Automatic waiver if financial organization error
An automatic waiver of the 60-day restriction may apply if:
An IRA owner may not complete more than one rollover per 12 months per taxpayer. One year must pass after the date of receipt of the distribution before an IRA owner is eligible to roll over another distribution.
Even though an individual may transfer a Required Minimum Distribution (RMD), they may not roll over an RMD. In any year for which an IRA owner is required to take an RMD, the first assets distributed from the IRA are considered by the IRS to have satisfied that year's RMD. Only after the RMD is satisfied for the year may an individual roll over assets from one IRA into another IRA. RMDs that are rolled over become a regular contribution, and if the IRA owner is ineligible for the contribution, it will become an excess contribution.
Traditional and Roth IRA owners must irrevocably designate in writing at the time of the rollover deposit that the contribution is to be treated as a rollover. Many financial organizations find a rollover certification form helpful in satisfying this requirement.
Select to Open Now
IRA Transfer
IRA Rollover
Check out our Individual Retirement Account (IRA) rates to see how we can help you reach your goals!
View our Retirement Tools designed to help give you insight on all the options available to you.
If you're looking for a customized approach to investing, reach out to our Investment Services team.
Confidential information such as account numbers and social security numbers should not be sent by email for security reasons. Instead, please contact us directly at 1-888-NASA-FCU, send us a secure message through Online Banking or Mobile Banking, or visit your nearest branch.
The content you are about to view is produced by a third party unaffiliated to NASA Federal Credit Union. NASA Federal takes no responsibility for the content of the page.